Imposter Syndrome in the Real World
What Is Imposter Syndrome Really?
If you read the academic literature, imposter syndrome is often described as a psychological pattern where capable people struggle to internalise their achievements and fear being exposed as a fraud. The term was first introduced by psychologists Pauline Clance and Suzanne Imes in 1978 and has since been studied extensively. Research suggests that imposter feelings can affect people at all levels, regardless of ability, experience or accomplishment.
All very interesting.
But what does imposter syndrome look like in the real world?
For me, it starts long before the job title, the promotion, or the successful career.
It starts in childhood.
The Foundations of Self-Belief
Born in 1973, I grew up in rural Shropshire. On the surface, there were many positive memories. Climbing trees, playing in streams, snowy winters and long summer days all feature in my recollections.
However, looking back with the benefit of hindsight, there was something else developing in the background.
A lack of self-belief.
As a child, I never really felt like I fitted in. After moving from a small rural school to a much larger town school at the age of seven, I struggled socially and academically. I wanted desperately to be accepted, but often found myself on the outside looking in.
Over time, that sense of not quite belonging became part of my identity.
The problem with these experiences is that they don't always stay in childhood. They often become the lens through which we judge ourselves as adults.
When Other People's Opinions Become Your Truth
By my teenage years, things had become more difficult.
Bullying had become a regular part of life and continued until I left school at sixteen. My highest academic achievement was a GCSE Grade D in Drama.
At home and at school, I was repeatedly exposed to messages that suggested I wasn't capable and wouldn't amount to much.
The phrases themselves are almost irrelevant now. What mattered was that I believed them.
When enough people tell you that you're not good enough, eventually you stop questioning whether they might be wrong.
You simply accept it as fact.
Psychological research supports this idea. Studies have
repeatedly shown that labels applied during childhood can significantly influence self-perception, confidence and future behaviour patterns. What starts as someone else's opinion can gradually become an individual's self-belief.
That was certainly true in my case.
Finding Something I Was Good At
When I left school, the bullying stopped.
Not because circumstances suddenly improved, but because I wasn't around the same people anymore. Unfortunately, the years that followed were characterised by anger and frustration. Some of that was undoubtedly youth, but much of it came from everything that had gone before. Then I discovered automotive mechanics. For the first time, I found something that made sense to me. Something I was genuinely good at.
By my early twenties, I had qualified as a motor mechanic and was beginning to build a career within the automotive industry.
As my career progressed, I moved from independent garages into franchised dealerships, eventually becoming a workshop controller and later a service manager. On paper, things were going well.
But confidence and competence are not always the same thing.
Success Doesn't Automatically Cure Self-Doubt
Many people assume that imposter syndrome disappears once success arrives. In my experience, that's simply not true.
Despite career progression, I still carried many of the beliefs that had been formed much earlier in life. After resigning as a service manager and experiencing significant challenges in my personal life, I decided I needed to reset. I focused heavily on personal and professional development and eventually achieved Master Technician status with Volkswagen.
At the time, this represented a significant achievement.
Yet I still doubted myself. I moved into apprentice training, then eventually became manager of the Volkswagen Apprenticeship Programme, responsible for around 850 apprentices across the Volkswagen Group. Surely that should have been enough evidence?
Apparently not. The self-doubt remained.
The Day Imposter Syndrome Became Real
The moment I truly recognised imposter syndrome came several years later.
Having left the apprenticeship programme, I joined an automotive consultancy as a management development consultant. The irony wasn't lost on me. A person who had once considered themselves a failed service manager was now coaching service managers.
Logically, I understood why I was there.
Emotionally, I wasn't always convinced.
A few years later, I found myself part of a team that secured responsibility for delivering Volkswagen Group's training offer, worth in excess of £28 million over three years. The contract included technical training programmes that had helped me become a Master Technician many years earlier.
Then came the day I walked into the Volkswagen Group National
Learning Centre in Milton Keynes as Contract Manager.
Around 150 technicians, parts advisors and sales executives were attending training.
Many were following a path I had once followed myself.
And despite everything that had happened in my career, the voice was still there.
"You don't belong here."
"You're not good enough."
"Sooner or later, they'll find out."
That is imposter syndrome in the real world. Not a shortage of capability. Not a lack of experience. A conflict between evidence and belief.
Why It Still Appears Today
Today, after leading national programmes, managing large contracts, running businesses and working with clients on people and business development strategies, imposter syndrome still occasionally appears.
Why?
My best guess is that the lack of self-belief ingrained so early in life sits so deep within my psyche that it is unlikely to ever completely disappear.
But here's the interesting part. It no longer controls me. In many ways, it fuels me. Not because I want to prove the doubters wrong anymore. But because I want others to understand that feeling vulnerable is normal.
It's OK not to have all the answers. It's OK to get things wrong. And it's certainly OK to experience self-doubt.
The reality is that many highly successful people experience exactly the same thing.
Final Thoughts
If there's one lesson I've learned, it's this:
Imposter syndrome isn't always a sign that you're incapable. Sometimes it's evidence of the journey you've travelled.
The child who felt excluded. The teenager who was told he was useless. The young adult trying to find his place. The consultant standing in front of people wondering if he belongs. They're all the same person. And perhaps that's the point.
Imposter syndrome doesn't make me weak.
It makes me authentic.
It makes me relatable.
Most importantly, it reminds me where I've come from.
And in many ways, that makes me exactly who I am.
Dave Bownes
Director,
Haynes Oliver Limited
Share this post: